Talk:Year of the Dragon Festival

From MHWiki
Revision as of 07:16, 25 January 2012 by MearsMan (talk | contribs) (response)

Different mouse populations for different players?

I watched my brother go on a hunt earlier and I noticed something interesting - his mouse populations at the Year of the Dragon Festival were different from mine! I had him try a few different setups, and by checking the trap effectiveness here's what he was able to attract:

No Charm - White, Grey, Brown, Cowardly, Field, Present, Dwarf, Red Envelope, Calligraphy (with SB+)
Firecracker charm - Field, Present, Dwarf, New Years, Red Envelope, Costumed Tiger, Calligraphy (with SB+)
Nitropop - Partyhead, New Years, Red Envelope, Costumed Rabbit, Calligraphy (with SB+)

My brother is currently ranked Hero, but he's never traveled past the Catacombs and has spent minimal time in Furoma. So this has me wondering: do hunter's of different ranks encounter different mouse populations at the Year of the Dragon Festival? Or does something different influence this? Either way, I feel we should look into this more. —MearsMan talk 23:27, 23 January 2012 (UTC)

That's interesting. We need some collaboration, maybe ask in the forums if the newer players would be willing to check. -- camomiletea 00:00, 24 January 2012 (UTC)
Here's a person on the forums reporting different mice populations, as a Master. I'm not altogether convinced that it's necessarily rank-based. I have a Hero friend, who seems to be catching the same stuff the higher ranked ones do. Maybe depends on the map-pieces owned or traps owned? -- camomiletea 00:18, 24 January 2012 (UTC)
Could it possibly have something to do with catching certain mice in the Furoma region? I'm just throwing out ideas, but I noticed most of the mice that are "missing" for the lower-level hunters are from Furoma and that, as far as I can tell, neither my brother nor the person you linked have caught a mouse from the Meditation Room or Pinnacle Chamber. —MearsMan talk 05:27, 24 January 2012 (UTC)
I looked again, and I was mistaken about my Hero friend... there are white, field and cowardly, etc. now. (And he's been to Furoma, has some Masters.) If it is rank-based, then Hero seems the last rank for the lower mice; Knights among my friends are catching student mice and none of those colored and lowly Gnawnia mice. Hopefully it will be clearer by tomorrow.
and we need to decide how to present this information... I'm thinking a separate table, because this is going to be confusing all in one table with the Xs. Suggestions, thoughts?-- camomiletea 06:04, 24 January 2012 (UTC)

Based on everything we've been able to discern thus far and by looking at the hunting results on Horntracker I feel that at this point it's fairly safe to say that hunters ranked Novice—Hero attract the first group of "Indigenous" mice while hunters ranked Knight and above encounter the second "Furoma" group. The only alternative to your idea that I can readily think of would be to do something similar to the King's Gauntlet article and have a table for each tier/charm setup (no charm, firecracker, nitropop, and dragon breath) with columns denoting which ranks can attract which mice (as is currently done with X's for charms). I keep going back and forth as to which would be the better option, though. What do you think? Would it be easier to make sense of two larger tables or four smaller ones? —MearsMan talk 07:16, 25 January 2012 (UTC)